Docs / Semantics / Degree / PositiveStandard

Positive standards and Interpretive Economy

import Linglib.Semantics.Degree.PositiveStandard

A standard is an upper set of degrees, and the positive form of a measure at it is the preimage of the standard. Kennedy's PositiveStandards are the degrees above the least, those from the greatest and those above a contextual threshold, and Interpretive Economy uses a standard the scale itself fixes when there is one. Reading "fixes" as invariance under every automorphism, the invariant standards are the trivial and the endpoint ones wherever an automorphism carries any degree between the endpoints to any other, so a contextual standard is admitted exactly on an open scale. Only the minimum and the maximum are complementary. A difference function measures on the ray above a degree and so takes the minimum standard, at which the positive form is a comparative.

Implementation notes

Kennedy states Interpretive Economy as maximizing the contribution of conventional meaning; reading the standards a scale contributes as those every automorphism fixes is this library's. The preference for the maximum on a totally closed scale is Kennedy's and stays a stipulation (Boundedness.defaultStandard).

References

Invariant standards

A standard of a scale is an upper set of its degrees, and the positive form at it holds of what the measure places in it, so that a stronger standard, a smaller upper set, entails a weaker one. A standard is invariant when the order alone singles it out, every automorphism of the degrees mapping it to itself. All degrees and none are invariant, as are the degrees above a least one and those from a greatest one, and where any degree between the endpoints is carried to any other by an automorphism, as on the canonical scales, these are all.

A standard is invariant when every order automorphism of the degrees maps it to itself.

def UpperSet.IsInvariantL57–58
{D : Type u_1} [Preorder D] (U : UpperSet D) :
  • U.IsInvariant = ∀ (f : D ≃o D), (UpperSet.map f) U = U

Used by UpperSet.isInvariant_bot, UpperSet.isInvariant_top, UpperSet.isInvariant_Ioi_of_isBot, UpperSet.isInvariant_Ici_of_isTop, UpperSet.IsInvariant.apply_mem, UpperSet.isInvariant_iff_of_exists_orderIso, UpperSet.forall_isInvariant_iff_of_exists_orderIso, Boundedness.isInvariant_degreeShape_iff, PositiveStandard.RequiresComparisonClass, Boundedness.Admits

L62
L64
L66–67
L69–70
L72–75

Where an automorphism carries any degree strictly between the endpoints to any other, the invariant standards are the trivial ones and the endpoint ones.

theorem UpperSet.isInvariant_iff_of_exists_orderIsoL82–124
{D : Type u_1} [LinearOrder D] {U : UpperSet D} (hI : ∃ (x : D), ¬IsBot x ∧ ¬IsTop x) (h : ∀ (x y : D), ¬IsBot x → ¬IsTop x → ¬IsBot y → ¬IsTop y → ∃ (f : D ≃o D), f x = y) :
U.IsInvariant ↔ U = ⊥ ∨ U = ⊤ ∨ (∃ (m : D), IsBot m ∧ U = Ioi m) ∨ ∃ (m : D), IsTop m ∧ U = Ici m

Built from

L126–141

Standards and Interpretive Economy

The positive form of a gradable predicate at a standard U is the preimage μ ⁻¹' U of the standard under its measure, true of what the measure places in the standard. Kennedy's standards are the degrees above the least, Set.Ioi ⊥, as for wet and bent; those from the greatest, Set.Ici ⊤, as for dry and full; and those above a contextual threshold θ, Set.Ioi θ, as for tall. When the least degree is below the greatest, the maximum standard is stronger than the minimum (UpperSet.Ioi_le_Ici), and the minimum standard is the weakest nontrivial one, covering the standard every degree meets (UpperSet.Ici_covBy_Ioi). Interpretive Economy maximizes the contribution of conventional meaning, so a scale with an endpoint rules out the contextual standard, and a totally closed scale admits both endpoint standards and prefers the maximum.

A positive standard is the kind of threshold the positive form compares a degree with, a contextual norm on an open scale and an endpoint on a closed one (Kennedy 2007), or a standard an adjective fixes lexically outside that choice.

inductive PositiveStandardL166–181

Derives DecidableEq, Repr.

Used by PositiveStandard.standards, PositiveStandard.RequiresComparisonClass, PositiveStandard.requiresComparisonClass_iff, PositiveStandard.Complementary, PositiveStandard.complementary_iff, Boundedness.Admits, Boundedness.instDecidableAdmits, Boundedness.defaultStandard, Boundedness.admits_withMin_iff

Used in Fragments/Adyghe/Clause, Fragments/Dutch/Adjectives, Fragments/Dutch/Verbs, Fragments/English/Verbs/Basic, Fragments/Finnish/Verbs and 20 more

L183–192
L196–200
L202–206
L208–215
L239–245
L291

Difference functions

The difference function of a measure μ at a degree d is Set.projIci d ∘ μ, which measures on the ray above d and sends every degree at or below d to d, the derived zero. The ray has a least degree (Boundedness.ofOrder_Ici), so Interpretive Economy admits the minimum standard for a difference function, giving the truth conditions of a comparative with standard d, and the maximum standard exactly when the scale of μ has one.

L312–318
L324–337
L359–364
L370–376
L386–392
L394–400