Docs / Studies / Studies.Barker2027

Scope

Barker, C. (2027). Annual Review of Linguistics, 13

Barker's survey takes Quantifier Raising as the general theory of scope and asks what restricts it. The orders in which the quantifiers of someone saw everyone raise give its two readings, the one formal constraint is that a logical form have a type analysis, which raising the subject alone does not, and with Lift raising derives the shifted verb of Flexible Montague Grammar. Among the empirical constraints, a tensed clause is an island for every and not for each, so no theory that sees a scope-taker through its readings fits both, while one that names the determiner does.

Implementation notes

  • A tree's words are determiner entries of the English fragment and other words as strings, and everyone is the determiner every with the noun one.

  • A tensed clause has the category S; an infinitival clause is a projection of to, a particle. An adjunction to a clause is a segment of the clause, so a constituent raised to the edge of an island is still inside it.

  • The inverse reading of a row is available when the embedded quantifier can raise to the edge of the sentence. The article's examples of relative and adjunct clauses, (19) and (20a), are in the rows and are not given trees.

  • The trees of the section on theories of scope are unlabelled, as the article's are, and their words are a separate type from the words of the island examples: those are strings, which have no denotations. A logical form is interpreted by Heim and Kratzer's rules, Functional Application and Predicate Abstraction, which the article adopts.

  • The type of each index is given with a logical form. The article reads it off the constituent that moved.

TODO

  • The island examples are judged by whether a constituent can raise, and their readings are labels of the rows. They are not the meanings of logical forms.

  • That Value Raising and Argument Raising are derivable in general, of which (16) is an instance, is not stated: it is a simulation of one system of rules by another.

  • Cooper storage, Combinatory Categorial Grammar and continuations are not formalized here, so that they assign the readings Quantifier Raising does is not stated.

  • That an island confines a scope-taker under every sequence of steps, and not only the one step to the edge of the sentence, is not proved.

References

Declarations

Scope by Quantifier Raising

The article's logical forms are interpreted by Function Application and Predicate Abstraction over an arbitrary model.

L98–104
L106–116
L120–127
L129–133
L149–153

The relative scope of the quantifiers of (5) depends on the order in which they raise: with someone raised last there is one person who saw everyone, and with everyone raised last each person may have been seen by another.

theorem meanings_linear_inverseL176–184
{E : Type} (M : Model E) :
meanings M ind linear = [⟨Interpreter.Ty.t, fun (x : (n : ℕ) → Interpreter.Ty.Dom (Interpreter.Base.Dom E Unit) (ind n)) => Quantifier.Det.some M.person {y : E | Quantifier.Det.every M.person {x : E | M.saw x y}}⟩] ∧ meanings M ind inverse = [⟨Interpreter.Ty.t, fun (x : (n : ℕ) → Interpreter.Ty.Dom (Interpreter.Base.Dom E Unit) (ind n)) => Quantifier.Det.every M.person {x : E | Quantifier.Det.some M.person {y : E | M.saw x y}}⟩]

Built from , , , ,

Type coherence is a constraint of its own: raising the subject of (5) alone is a step of Quantifier Raising, and its result has no type analysis, the object still where it cannot compose.

theorem isLogicalForm_not_coherentL191–197

Built from , ,

L200–205

Lift and Flexible Montague Grammar

Lift (9) is a manipulation of logical forms as Quantifier Raising is: A becomes [n [tₙ A]], the trace of the type of a function of A. With it, raising derives the type shifts of Flexible Montague Grammar.

The standard interpretation of (16) is the verb of (14), saw with both arguments raised and the first to combine taking scope over the second: λQ λP. Q(λx. P(λy. saw x y)). Argument Raising is here a theorem of Quantifier Raising with Lift.

theorem meanings_argumentRaisingL229–234

Built from , , ,

Theories of islands

L240–245
L247–249

The examples

L288–289

What the theories predict