Docs / Studies / Studies.Prior1967
Past, Present and Future
Prior, A. (1967). Oxford University Press
Chapter III of Prior's book correlates the postulates of tense logic with the structure of time,
through the reading of F, P, G and H as quantifiers over later and earlier dates that
Semantics/Tense/Quantificational.lean takes as its definition. Time's density matters only to a
strict later than: it refutes CFpFFp when discrete, and
a reflexive one verifies it regardless. A time with a beginning and no end
keeps CGpFp and loses its mirror image. Prior's law CMNMpNMp
holds exactly when time branches neither way, which
falls short of trichotomy, and CFPpAApPpFp and CPFpAApPpFp
come apart on a fork.
TODO
- The metric tense logic of Chapter VI, the Ockhamist and Peircean formalizations of Chapter VII
(see
Semantics/Modality/BranchingTime.lean), and the rest of the book.
References
- Prior 1967, Past, Present and Future
Declarations
If later than were reflexive, CFpFFp would be verified even if time were not dense (p. 39).
The reflexive later than is the relation of the nonpast.
If time has a beginning and no end, it keeps CGpFp and loses the mirror image CHpPp, so the
mirror-image rule has to go (p. 40).
CMNMpNMp (p. 38), with M the possibility of the top element (diamond_toSetRel_top),
holds exactly when time branches neither way.
{T : Type u_1} [PartialOrder T] :
(∀ (p : T → Prop) (t : T), ModalLogic.Diamond ⊤.toSetRel (fun (u : T) => ¬ModalLogic.Diamond ⊤.toSetRel p u) t → ¬ModalLogic.Diamond ⊤.toSetRel p t) ↔ IsForestOrder T ∧ IsForestOrder Tᵒᵈ
CMNMpNMp holds on two unconnected lines, where a date of one is neither identical with, later
than nor earlier than a date of the other, so the law does not require trichotomy.
A time with a root and two branches.
- Fork = WithBot (Unit ⊕ Unit)
CFPpAApPpFp and CPFpAApPpFp (p. 52) come apart on a fork, where no time branches to the left
and one branches to the right.