Docs / Studies / Studies.MartyEtAl2026

Quantifying Presupposition Projection

Marty, P., Elliott, P. D., Kalomoiros, A. & Romoli, J. (2026). In Proceedings of Sinn und Bedeutung 30 (pp. 744–761). Goethe University Frankfurt

Marty, Elliott, Kalomoiros and Romoli test how the existence presupposition of the present in front of him and the gender presupposition of her project from the scope of each, none and exactly one, against pictures of four children (Data/Statistics/MartyEtAl2026). Each of their interpretive options is a trivalent quantifier, from a quantifier and a three-valued scope to a three-valued sentence; the options reproduce Table 2 but for one cell, and Strong Kleene agrees with universal projection on these quantifiers. Only intermediate projection separates the target pictures of the negated exactly one as observed, and the model that adds it to universal projection and local accommodation fits best.

Implementation notes

  • A sentence is accepted at a picture under an option where its value is true, presupposition and assertion conjoined as in §2. Local accommodation is ambiguous between the scope and the trigger, so its value is the join of the two.
  • Intermediate projection is George's 2008 deployment with concern for disappointment, the theory note 5 credits with it alone.

References

The interpretive options of §2

L58–63
L66–70
L73–77
L79–85

The target sentences

L152–157

Intermediate projection, (6) and (7c), is George's deployment with concern for disappointment: each and exactly one are true where their scope is true of the children they count, and none where its scope is defined of every child and true of none.

theorem deployWithConcern_quantifier_eq_true_iffL186–205

Built from

The pictures

L265–267

Table 2

The design and the results

Intermediate projection alone accepts nm-neg with the Target-2 picture and rejects it with the Target-1 picture, and in both experiments the Target-2 picture is accepted more often.

theorem accepts_nmNeg_iffL312–318

Built from ,

Local accommodation alone accepts m-neg with the Target-1 picture, where no child has a present in Experiment 1 and every child is a boy in Experiment 2; in both experiments that picture is accepted more often than the False picture and than m-pos with its Target-1 picture.

theorem accepts_mNeg_target1_iffL320–328

Built from ,

L343–349
L352–361