Docs / Studies / Studies.Sbardolini2026

Negative Polarity, Presuppositions, and the Harmony Hypothesis

Sbardolini, G. (2026). In Proceedings of Sinn und Bedeutung 30 (pp. 992–1006). Goethe University Frankfurt

Sbardolini takes any to be disharmonious: any x: F x is true when everything is F and false when nothing is. Truth preservation closed under contraposition then relates any two instances of a predicate, as Prior's tonk does, and English keeps its logic non-trivial by never committing a speaker to any: an occurrence is grammatical only if its environment is not Strawson upward monotone. A non-constant Strawson downward-entailing environment never is; unlike the condition of von Fintel and Gajewski, this one admits the restrictor of most, and, against Ladusaw, it excludes tautologies.

Implementation notes

  • An environment is the function of the slot F in the paper's table of predictions, over sets of individuals or of worlds, which entail one another by inclusion. IsSUM takes at least one premise; with none, the restrictor of the singular definite would fail it.

TODO

  • Polar questions, imperatives, generics, plural definites, both, and the scope of too.

References

Disharmony

Any consequence relation that contains truth preservation, validates contraposition and is transitive relates every instance of a predicate to every other, as Prior's tonk relates every sentence to every other (Prior 1960): any trivializes classical consequence.

theorem trivialityL87–96
{E : Type u_1} {W : Type u_2} (F : E → W → Prop) (R : (W → Trivalent) → (W → Trivalent) → Prop) (hR : ∀ ⦃φ ψ : W → Trivalent⦄, Trivalent.posExt φ ⊆ Trivalent.posExt ψ → R φ ψ) (hcon : ∀ ⦃φ ψ : W → Trivalent⦄, R φ ψ → R ψᶜ φᶜ) (htrans : ∀ ⦃φ ψ χ : W → Trivalent⦄, R φ ψ → R ψ χ → R φ χ) (b c : E) :
R (atom F b) (atom F c)

Built from

The licensing condition

L106–111
L122–130

Environments

The table of predictions

L281–285
L311–314

Rival conditions

Most professors who understand anything are very appreciative (7c): the restrictor of most is neither Strawson downward entailing, which von Fintel's condition and Gajewski's ask (von Fintel 1999, Gajewski 2011), nor SUM, so the Harmony hypothesis licenses any there and they do not.

theorem restrictor_mostL331–339
{W : Type u_2} [Nonempty W] :
(¬∀ (B : Set (Fin 3)), Presupposition.IsStrawsonDE (restrictor Quantifier.Det.most B)) ∧ ¬∀ (B : Set (Fin 3)), IsSUM (restrictor Quantifier.Det.most B)

Built from ,

*Zero or more students read anything (12a): a tautology is downward entailing, so Ladusaw's condition licenses any in it (Ladusaw 1979), but it carries no strength of negation and is SUM, so neither von Fintel's condition nor the Harmony hypothesis does.

theorem tautologyL341–349

Built from ,

Possibility modals