Docs / Studies / Studies.George2008

A New Predictive Theory of Presupposition Projection

George, B. R. (2008). In Proceedings of SALT 18 (pp. 358–375)

George derives projection from the classical meaning of an operator by deploying it on the repairs of its arguments, which replace presupposition failure by falsehood or by truth. A quantifier considers the repair by truth only when its argument is true of nothing in a set it depends on, and deployment fails where an argument is disappointing, its presupposition alone ruling out a truth still possible. So each and none presuppose that the scope is defined throughout the restrictor, exactly n is true where n individuals are and disappointing where fewer than n are defined, and conjunction becomes asymmetric.

Implementation notes

  • The definitions are stated for the nuclear scope of a determiner, the quantifier it makes of a classical restrictor, which is its own only repair. A relevant set is one the quantifier DependsOn, and the repair by truth is available where some relevant set holds no individual of which the argument is true, which is the paper's note 10 reading of "the relevant set".

TODO

  • Presuppositional restrictors (§3.1) and at least one (§3.2): deployment on a three-valued restrictor.

References

  • George 2008, A New Predictive Theory of Presupposition Projection
  • Peters 1979, A Truth-Conditional Formulation of Karttunen’s Account of Presupposition

Repairs and deployment: Definitions 1–4

L62–67

Disappointment: Definitions 5–7

L82–85
L104–106

Relevant sets of determiners

Predictions for quantifiers: §3

Connectives: §2.1 and §2.3.1