Docs / Studies / Studies.Chierchia1989

Structured Meanings, Thematic Roles and Control

Chierchia, G. (1989). In Properties, Types and Meaning, Volume II: Semantic Issues (pp. 131–166). Kluwer Academic Publishers

Chierchia takes the infinitive of a control structure to denote a property, and a thematic role to be a partial function from an eventuality to one of its constituents. Control is then one schema on the relations that take properties: if a relation holds of a property, it holds of the proposition that the bearer of a designated role has it. The controller is a co-argument because a role picks a constituent, and unique because a role is a function. On the strict form of the schema the role must have a bearer, so an operation that deletes the controller has no value, which is why it was tried to win is out; on the weak form, which holds only when the bearer is present, passive leaves someone or other as the controller, the implicit control of it was decided to leave.

The English verbs bear the schema out as far as their entries record it. Every verb whose object controls has a passive, the object surviving as subject, and a verb whose subject controls has a passive only if it has a frame without a controlled complement, the weaker hypothesis Chierchia adopts for teach and try.

Implementation notes

Propositions are the elements of any complete lattice, entailment its order. An eventuality's constituents other than the property are a type X, and a relation has one frame taking a property and one taking a proposition, which Chierchia writes as one polymorphic relation. Passive is stated for eventualities that pair an agent with the rest.

TODO

  • The default hierarchy of roles that fills in the controller, theme before goal before agent, is not tested: the entries of the English control verbs record no entailment profiles for their participants, so no role label is derivable for them.
  • The entries record whether a verb passivizes as one value for the verb, where the schema predicts it frame by frame: promise passivizes with a noun-phrase object and not with an infinitive. exists_uncontrolled_of_passivizable is the most the entries support.
  • Purpose clauses and control by the theme of a ditransitive are not formalized.

References

The control schema

L65–69
L78–80

A relation satisfying the strict schema has the bearer of the controlling role among the constituents of each of its eventualities.

theorem Strict.isSomeL82–86
{E : Type u_1} {Φ : Type u_2} {X : Type u_3} [CompleteLattice Φ] {rP : (E → Φ) → X → Φ} {rS : Φ → X → Φ} {θ : X → Option E} (h : Strict rP rS θ) (x : X) :
(θ x).isSome = true

Built from

L89–90

A relation that reads its property only at an argument, taken at that argument's role, satisfies the strict schema.

theorem strict_of_eqL92–96
{E : Type u_1} {Φ : Type u_2} {X : Type u_3} [CompleteLattice Φ] {rP : (E → Φ) → X → Φ} {rS : Φ → X → Φ} {c : X → E} (h : ∀ (P : E → Φ) (x : X), rP P x = rS (P (c x)) x) :
Strict rP rS fun (x : X) => some (c x)

Built from

L98–100

Under the weak schema with the agent as controller, the passive of a relation entails that for some agent the relation holds of the proposition that the agent has the property.

theorem pas_leL103–108
{E : Type u_1} {Φ : Type u_2} {Y : Type u_4} [CompleteLattice Φ] {rP : (E → Φ) → E × Y → Φ} {rS : Φ → E × Y → Φ} (h : Weak rP rS fun (x : E × Y) => match x with | (a, snd) => some a) (P : E → Φ) (y : Y) :
pas rP P y ≤ ⨆ (a : E), rS (P a) (a, y)

Built from ,

The English verbs