On the analysis of Montague, Bach, Dowty and Chierchia the complement of try, persuade or
seem denotes a property, and the predicate denotes a relation R : (E → Φ) → X → Ψ between a
property and its other arguments X, with Φ the propositions. What is called control and
raising are then two answers to how much of the property the relation reads. Given the argument
c : X → E the property is understood of, the relation is raising at c when it reads only the
proposition P (c x), and controlled at c when it reads that proposition and the arguments
x. A raising relation is controlled, and a controlled one is exactly a relation to a
proposition with the property applied to c x, so an
analysis on which the complement denotes a proposition describes the controlled relations and no
others. A raising relation entails nothing about c x
that it does not entail of everything: the argument is not a semantic argument of the relation, as
no participant of a raising verb fills the slot it raises into (Diathesis.IsRaising).
A controlled relation reads the property at the argument itself. In Landau's two-tiered theory
that is one of two ways control is established, predication, found under predicates that
introduce no attitude. Under an attitude predicate the complement is read at a coordinate of the
reported context, its author or addressee, as the holder of the attitude represents it: the
relation is logophoric at a concept c of centers when it reads the property only through the
centers whose value under c has it, which is a relation to a
proposition, the one self-ascribed. Self-ascription over
a set of alternatives is logophoric, and it is
controlled at an argument when the concept
takes that argument as its value throughout the alternatives, so that the two readings come apart
only where the holder may mistake who the coordinate is.
Implementation notes
IsRaisingAt and IsControlledAt are predicates on the bare relation, as Monotone is on a
function, and a relation that reads the whole property satisfies neither. Being controlled is
Function.FactorsThrough evaluation at c x, for each x. The argument c is any function of
the other arguments, the bearer of a thematic role in Chierchia's sense; the participant in a
slot is the case of a projection. Equality in Φ is logical equivalence when propositions are
sets of worlds.
References