Docs / Studies / Studies.Dowty1985

On Recent Analyses of the Semantics of Control

Dowty, D. R. (1985). Linguistics and Philosophy, 8(3), 291–331

Dowty compares two analyses of the infinitive complements of Equi and Raising verbs. On the first the complement denotes a proposition, whose subject the rules of control supply; on the second, Montague's, it denotes a property like any other verb phrase, and control is an entailment of the verb. He argues that nothing in the semantics favours the first. A relation to a proposition whose subject must be the matrix argument is a relation to a property and that argument, "a function of just two things after all". Raising verbs are the relations to a property that depend only on the proposition it forms with the subject, which may be said by positing a property of propositions or without one, and they are a proper subclass of the relations of their type. An Equi verb entails something of its subject as such; a verb with the raising property entails of its subject only what it entails of everything, so the two classes are told apart by lexical entailments, not by logical type.

Implementation notes

Propositions are sets of worlds, so the necessary equivalence of two propositions in the postulates is their equality. A noun-phrase meaning is left as any type N: the postulates for Raising verbs range over noun-phrase meanings in general, those for Equi verbs over the sublimations of individuals, and the difference plays no part in the results here. The paper's arguments from scope, from dummy subjects and from mixed Raising-Equi verbs are not formalized.

References

  • Dowty 1985, On Recent Analyses of the Semantics of Control

Declarations

L47–51

A relation between a property and a noun-phrase meaning comes from an R-analysis exactly when it reads the property only at that noun-phrase meaning, so the R-analysis describes a function of two things.

theorem rAnalysis_iffL54–59
{W : Type u_1} {N : Type u_2} {δ : (N → W → Prop) → N → W → Prop} :
(∃ (r : (W → Prop) → N → W → Prop), δ = ofRAnalysis r) ↔ ArgumentStructure.IsControlledAt δ id

Built from

L85–87

A verb that satisfies the Raising postulate has only trivial entailments about its subject: what it entails of its subject at a world, it entails there of every noun-phrase meaning.

theorem postulate9_trivialL90–95
{W : Type u_1} {N : Type u_2} {δ : (N → W → Prop) → N → W → Prop} (h : Postulate15 δ) {α : N → W → Prop} (hα : ∀ (P : N → W → Prop) (a : N) (w : W), δ P a w → α a w) {P : N → W → Prop} {a : N} {w : W} (hδ : δ P a w) (b : N) :
α b w

Built from