Bridge: DG Ellipsis → Steedman's Ellipsis Taxonomy #
Maps the DG catena-based ellipsis taxonomy to [Ste00a]'s ellipsis
types (Steedman2000.EllipsisType).
Key result: gapping (from Steedman's taxonomy) is a special case of catena-ellipsis — the elided verb is always a singleton catena that is not a constituent.
Bridges #
DepGrammar.Ellipsis.EllipsisType→Steedman2000.EllipsisTypeDepGrammar.Ellipsis.gappingTree/gappingElided→ catena-not-constituent proof
Map DG ellipsis types to Steedman2000.EllipsisType.
Not all DG types have Steedman equivalents (pseudogapping/fragmentAnswer don't).
Equations
- DepGrammar.Ellipsis.toGappingEllipsisType DepGrammar.Ellipsis.EllipsisType.vpEllipsis = some Steedman2000.EllipsisType.vpEllipsis
- DepGrammar.Ellipsis.toGappingEllipsisType DepGrammar.Ellipsis.EllipsisType.gapping = some Steedman2000.EllipsisType.gapping
- DepGrammar.Ellipsis.toGappingEllipsisType DepGrammar.Ellipsis.EllipsisType.stripping = some Steedman2000.EllipsisType.stripping
- DepGrammar.Ellipsis.toGappingEllipsisType DepGrammar.Ellipsis.EllipsisType.sluicing = some Steedman2000.EllipsisType.sluicing
- DepGrammar.Ellipsis.toGappingEllipsisType DepGrammar.Ellipsis.EllipsisType.pseudogapping = none
- DepGrammar.Ellipsis.toGappingEllipsisType DepGrammar.Ellipsis.EllipsisType.fragmentAnswer = none
Instances For
Gapping (from Steedman's taxonomy) is a special case of catena-ellipsis. The verb alone is elided — always a singleton catena.
theorem
DepGrammar.Ellipsis.gapping_always_catena_not_constituent :
Catena.isCatena gappingTree.deps gappingElided = true ∧ Catena.isConstituent gappingTree.deps 3 gappingElided = false
Gapping always elides a non-constituent catena: the verb alone is a catena (trivially) but never a constituent (its subtree includes subject and object).