Docs / Studies / Studies.Spector2014

Scalar implicatures, blindness and common knowledge: Comments on Magri (2011)

Spector, B. (2014). In Pragmatics, Semantics and the Case of Scalar Implicatures. Palgrave Macmillan

Spector proposes that a sentence is infelicitous when every one of its alternatives is trivial in the context: known to be false, known to be true, or equivalent there to the sentence itself. Contextually equivalent alternatives are the case that rules out both some and each of siblings who share a name, where a mismatch between the strengthened meaning and common knowledge rules out only some. The condition also rules out John has one wife, whose strengthened meaning agrees with common knowledge, and it allows any numeral where nothing is known. Triviality is lost as the context grows, so information that falls short of common knowledge leaves a sentence felicitous.

Implementation notes

A context is the set of worlds compatible with common knowledge, and contextual equivalence of φ and ψ in C is written φ ∩ C = ψ ∩ C. Numerals have their at least meaning, Set.Ici over the number of wives, gloves or brothers.

TODO

  • Speaker-equivalence, and the conditions on restrictors and on the smallest constituent in which two lexical items are speaker-equivalent, are not represented.

References

Trivial alternatives

L55–57
L59
L61–62
L79–81

Some and each

The alternatives some of these kids and each of these kids over the vertices of the triangle of opposition, siblings sharing their last name in the worlds other than someNotAll.

Numerals

L147–150