Docs / Logic / Aristotelian / Triangle

The triangle of opposition

import Linglib.Logic.Aristotelian.Triangle · namespace Aristotelian

A square of opposition divides its algebra into three parts, E, A, and between them the conjunction of the two particulars: the vertices of Horn's triangle of opposition. Horn traces this trichotomy to De Morgan and to Jespersen's tripartition into all, some and none, whose middle term is neither the I nor the O corner but their conjunction; modally the vertices are the impossible, the contingent and the necessary.

Triangle is the type of the three vertices, and serves as the state space of a scalar item with its stronger alternative. Each corner of the square is the set of vertices at which it holds, and these four sets form a square in Finset Triangle. The vertices are ordered by the affirmative corners they lie in, which is the scale none < some but not all < all: some holds above the bottom vertex and all at the top.

References

Declarations

The vertices of the triangle of opposition, in scale order.

inductive TriangleL33–41
  • none : Triangle

    None, the universal negative E.

  • someNotAll : Triangle

    Some but not all, the conjunction of the two particulars I and O.

  • all : Triangle

    All, the universal affirmative A.

Derives DecidableEq, Repr, Fintype.

Instances FrankeBergen2020.instMembershipTriangleWorld

Used by Triangle.corners, Triangle.instLE, Triangle.instDecidableLE, Triangle.instLinearOrder, Triangle.instBoundedOrder, Triangle.mem_corners_I, Triangle.mem_corners_A, Triangle.mem_corners_O, Triangle.mem_corners_E

Used in Logic/Aristotelian/Square/Hom, BrochhagenFrankeVanRooij2018, ChemlaSpector2011, FrankeBergen2020, HuangSpelkeSnedeker2013 and 5 more

L55–57
L59
L74
L76
L84
L86