Docs / Studies / Studies.Larson1998

Events and Modification in Nominals

Larson, R. K. (1998). In Proceedings of SALT VIII (pp. 145–168). Cornell University

On Larson's analysis a noun is a relation of individuals to events and an adjective a set of individuals and events. An adjective modifies a noun at the individual or at the event, and both readings are intersective.

With the event closed, a noun holds of the domain of its relation, and a noun modified at the event holds of the preimage of the adjective. Nouns with the same domain can differ in that preimage, so this reading is not a function of the noun's extension. An adjective that holds of no event, or of no individual, has one reading, and a coordination has the readings its conjuncts share. Under a universal quantifier over events, a modified nominal does not entail the bare one.

Implementation notes

  • The comparison class of an adjective is left out.
  • A reading excluded on pragmatic grounds is an empty relation.
  • Where the event quantifier is suppressed, the event is closed existentially. The generic quantifier is a determiner denotation on events, with some and every the instances considered.

TODO

  • The contrast of the invisible visible stars with the visible invisible stars is not derived.
  • The adverbial readings in predicate position and those of the adjectives of infrequency are not formalized.

References

The two rules of modification

L69
L71
L74–76

There are no nonintersective readings (§3.1): predicated of the event as of the individual, the adjective is intersected with the noun, on dancings in place of dancers.

theorem isIntersective_ofEventL81–84
{X : Type u_1} {Ev : Type u_2} (A : Set (X ⊕ Ev)) :

Built from

L87–88

The event closed

The individuals a noun is true of are the domain of its relation.

L96–98
L102–104
L107–109

(11), for nouns as §3 carries it over from verbs and adverbs: that the dancers are the singers does not make the beautiful dancers the beautiful singers when the adjective is predicated of the event, on first-order grounds and with no appeal to other worlds.

theorem exists_dom_eq_dom_ofEvent_neL111–122
:
∃ (X : Type) (Ev : Type) (dancing : SetRel X Ev) (singing : SetRel X Ev) (beautiful : Set (X ⊕ Ev)), dancing.dom = singing.dom ∧ (ofEvent beautiful dancing).dom ≠ (ofEvent beautiful singing).dom

Built from

The reading on which the adjective is predicated of the event is not a function of the extension of the noun, so an analysis on which the adjective is a function of the noun must take the noun's intension, as the one in (3) does.

theorem exists_not_factorsThrough_dom_ofEventL124–131
:
∃ (X : Type) (Ev : Type) (A : Set (X ⊕ Ev)), ¬Function.FactorsThrough (fun (R : SetRel X Ev) => (ofEvent A R).dom) SetRel.dom

Built from

L134–141

Sortal restrictions and coordination

The coordination of two adjectives is their intersection, so it is false on every parameter outside the ones its conjuncts share, and a strictly intersective adjective beside a strictly nonintersective one leaves no reading.

theorem isFalseOn_inter_of_notMem_inter(17), (18)L168–176
{X : Type u_1} {Ev : Type u_2} {A B : Set (X ⊕ Ev)} {s t : Finset Parameter} (hA : ∀ p ∉ s, IsFalseOn A p) (hB : ∀ p ∉ t, IsFalseOn B p) {p : Parameter} (hp : p ∉ s ∩ t) :
IsFalseOn (A ∩ B) p

Built from ,

The examples

L185–191

The event quantifier

L221–224
L230–232

With a quantifier that lacks existential import, (20c) does not entail (19c): of someone who never dances, every relevant dancing is beautiful, and not every relevant event is a dancing.

theorem exists_modifiedNominal_every_not_predicateNominalL251–257
:
∃ (X : Type) (Ev : Type) (Con : SetRel X Ev) (R : SetRel X Ev) (A : Set (X ⊕ Ev)) (x : X), modifiedNominal Quantifier.Det.every Con A R x ∧ ¬predicateNominal Quantifier.Det.every Con R x

Built from ,