Docs / Studies / Studies.GordonGroszGilliom1993

Pronouns, Names, and the Centering of Attention in Discourse

Gordon, P. C., Grosz, B. J. & Gilliom, L. A. (1993). Cognitive Science, 17(3), 311–347

This file treats the repeated-name penalty, the slower reading of an utterance that realizes its backward-looking center by a repeated name, as a marker of that center. Where a passage uses no pronoun, only the unconditional form of Rule 1 predicts it. Grosz, Joshi, and Weinstein's center, the highest-ranked forward-looking center of the previous utterance that the current one realizes, mispredicts three of the twelve tested entities; the paper's revision, the current utterance's subject, mispredicts one, and that subject when it was surface-initial or the subject before none. Grammatical roles alone cannot separate Experiments 4 and 5.

Implementation notes

  • An utterance lists, in surface order, the named entities and the new subjects of the critical sentences. A possessor and the object of a preposition are other roles, and Tommy is an object in sentences 2 to 4 of Experiment 1, as the paper describes him. Realization is direct: the painting that Experiment 2A's painted implies is not among the forward-looking centers.
  • A tested entity is a cell: the critical sentence in a condition that names it, after the sentence before it. Sentences 3 and 4 of Experiment 1 share an analysis.
  • A test finds its effect when its by-subjects and by-passages p-values are below .05, and a statistic printed as less than 1 finds none. Experiment 2B's test of its three conditions speaks for both of its entities. Experiment 5 prints no test per condition, and the paper reads a main effect of pronominalization without an interaction as a penalty in both.

References

Declarations

The sample passages

The critical sentences realize each named entity by form f or g, a pronoun or a repeated name.

L113–115

The tested entities

L148–156
L158–171
L173–184

The findings

L194

Rule 1

In every condition of Experiment 1, Rule 1 holds of the third sentence, and its unconditional form fails exactly in the name-name condition, whose passages showed the penalty (p. 341).

theorem rule1_nameNameL224–230

Built from , , ,

Which entity is the backward-looking center

The backward-looking center of Grosz, Joshi, and Weinstein mispredicts the penalty exactly for the fronted centers of Experiment 2 and the shifted subject of Experiment 4: it is the fronted entity of Experiment 2 and Debbie after a sentence that realized her as a possessor (p. 342).

theorem cbPenalty_mispredictionsL241–246

Built from , ,

Prominence in the previous sentence

L273

Debbie in Experiment 4 and Fred in Experiment 5 have the same roles in both sentences, a possessor in the earlier and the subject of the critical one, but only Fred bears the penalty, so no account that reads only an entity's grammatical roles in the two sentences fits both.

theorem not_roleFactoredL286–302

Built from , , ,