A coarser question raises the listener's probability of the answer at a state.
Docs / Pragmatics / Probabilistic / QUD
Speakers who address a question
import Linglib.Pragmatics.Probabilistic.QUD · namespace RSA
A question under discussion is a function q : W → X from states to answers. In the models of
Kao and colleagues the speaker knows the answer q w at her state and is
informative about the answer alone: she addresses the pushforward L.map q of the listener's
belief about the state. At the identity question she is the speaker who knows the
state, at a constant one she only weighs costs,
and a coarser question lets her say more.
Under a literal listener she produces an utterance exactly when it is true at a state of positive
prior with her answer, whether or
not it is true at hers. A listener unsure of the question holds it as a latent coordinate of the
state, as in lexical uncertainty, and such an utterance leads her to states where it is false,
which is how the models derive hyperbole, metaphor and irony. The question is sufficient for the
listener: she learns the speaker's answer, and given the
answer, or the question and the answer when she is unsure of the
question, she believes what the prior does. In
these models an utterance names one coordinate of the state, and at a prior that factors through
that coordinate the literal listener does not depend on its
marginal.
References
- Kao et al. 2014, Nonliteral Understanding of Number Words
- Kao et al. 2014, Formalizing the Pragmatics of Metaphor Understanding
- Kao & Goodman 2015, Let’s Talk (Ironically) About the Weather: Modeling Verbal Irony formalized
Declarations
The speaker
The speaker who addresses the question q. At the state w she knows the answer q w and
soft-maximizes the log of the listener's probability of that answer, less the cost.
- qudSpeaker α C L q w = (speaker α C (⇑(L.map q)) MeasureTheory.Measure.dirac) (q w)
Used by instIsZeroOrProbabilityMeasureQudSpeaker, qudSpeaker_eq_of_eq, qudSpeaker_id, qudSpeaker_const, qudSpeaker_apply_singleton_ne_zero_of_coarser, qudSpeaker_literalListener_apply_singleton_ne_zero_iff, listener_prod_fst_qudSpeaker_literalListener_apply_singleton_ne_zero_iff, cond_listener_qudSpeaker_preimage, cond_listener_prod_qudSpeaker_preimage
Used in KaoBergenEtAl2014, KaoGoodman2015, KaoWuEtAl2014, ScontrasPearl2021, SpinosoDiPianoEtAl2025
Built from
Built from
At the identity question she is the speaker who knows the state.
Built from
At a constant question the answer tells the listener nothing and she only weighs costs.
Built from
A coarser question lets her say more: an utterance she can produce addressing a question she can produce addressing any question that identifies at least the states it does.
Built from
Nonliteral production. The speaker who addresses a question to a literal listener produces an utterance exactly when it is true at a state of positive prior with the same answer as hers, whether or not it is true at her own state.
Built from
The listener
A meaning under uncertainty about the question is possible after an utterance exactly when it has positive prior and, under some question of positive prior, shares its answer with a state of positive prior where the utterance is true.
Built from
A question is sufficient for the listener. Against a speaker who addresses a question, the listener who learns the speaker's answer, at a state where the speaker can produce the utterance, holds the prior conditioned on that answer.
Built from
A listener unsure of the question who learns the question and the speaker's answer to it, at a state where the speaker can produce the utterance, holds the prior conditioned on them.
Built from