Docs / Studies / Studies.Simons2005

Dividing Things Up: The Semantics of Or and the Modal/Or Interaction

Simons, M. (2005). Natural Language Semantics, 13(3), 271–316

Simons 2005 takes an or coordination to denote the set of its disjuncts' denotations and to divide up a set of worlds by them: the set is super covered, each disjunct meeting it and the disjuncts together covering it. On its non-disjunctive reading Jane must sing or dance is true when the singing and the dancing worlds super cover the accessible worlds, and Jane may sing or dance when they super cover some of them, which holds exactly when each disjunct is possible. The modals are thus Kratzer and Shimoyama's with their distribution requirement built into the truth conditions. Unembedded, φ or ψ is true at a world of a set the disjuncts super cover, which is classical disjunction of consistent disjuncts, and the pragmatic Genuineness constraint, that the set lie among the speaker's epistemic possibilities, reduces the disjunctive reading of might φ or might ψ to its free-choice reading, which is why epistemic or sentences seem to lack the disjunctive reading (Zimmermann 2000).

Disjuncts are expected to be alternatives to one another, which three enhanced super covers make precise: Non-Containment, No Total Overlap, and Alternativeness, under which each disjunct contains a world of the set that no other disjunct contains. A disjunct that entails another within the worlds the set is drawn from violates Alternativeness on every such set, whether the entailment is logical, comes from the speaker's beliefs under Genuineness, or comes from the modal's domain (§6.2).

Implementation notes

  • Propositions are sets of worlds and the accessible worlds are R w. The propositions of Kratzer & Shimoyama 2002 are predicates on worlds and their accessibility a relation, reached through SetRel.ofSuccessors R. The appendix adapts the truth conditions to Kratzer's semantics by replacing the accessible worlds with the g-closest worlds, which is a choice of R.
  • The No Total Overlap constraint (107) is mathlib's IsAntichain (· ⊆ ·) on the disjuncts.
  • The unification of fn. 10 applied to a single proposition makes MUST[φ] require the accessible worlds to be nonempty (mem_must_singleton_iff), which (14) does not.

TODO

  • The syntax of §§3–4, ATB movement of the modal and the Rule of Independent Composition (51), and the disjunctive readings of narrow or sentences (§5.2).
  • The truth conditions without the Limit Assumption (§8.3).
  • The judgments (98)–(104) as Data/Examples rows paired with models of their entailments.

References

Non-disjunctive readings (§2)

L76–77
L80–82
L84–88
L91–92

MAY is the possibility of Kratzer & Shimoyama 2002 together with their distribution requirement, that each alternative be possible (p. 278).

theorem mem_may_iff_kann_and_distributionL94–109
{W : Type u_1} {R : W → Set W} {C : Set (Set W)} {w : W} :
w ∈ may R C ↔ C.Nonempty ∧ (∀ q ∈ KratzerShimoyama2002.kann (SetRel.ofSuccessors R) {p : W → Prop | {w : W | p w} ∈ C}, q w) ∧ KratzerShimoyama2002.distribution (SetRel.ofSuccessors R) {p : W → Prop | {w : W | p w} ∈ C} w

Built from

Jane's permissions and obligations (§2)

The worlds record whether Jane sings and whether she dances.

Disjunctive readings (§5)

An unembedded or coordination is classical disjunction of consistent disjuncts: true where some disjunct is, provided that none is contradictory.

theorem mem_orCoordination_iffL175–183
{W : Type u_1} {C : Set (Set W)} {w : W} :
w ∈ orCoordination C ↔ w ∈ ⋃₀ C ∧ ∀ c ∈ C, c.Nonempty

Built from

L186–188

If what is possibly possible is possible, the disjunctive reading of might φ or might ψ under the Genuineness constraint, (96), is its non-disjunctive reading: φ and ψ are both possible, (97).

theorem mem_may_of_genuineL190–204
{W : Type u_1} {R : W → Set W} {w : W} {φ ψ : Set W} (htrans : ∀ v ∈ R w, R v ⊆ R w) (h : ∃ (S : Set W), w ∈ S ∧ MinimalCovering.IsSuperCover {may R {φ}, may R {ψ}} S ∧ S ⊆ R w) :
w ∈ may R {φ, ψ}

Built from

L207–220

Alternativeness (§6)

L235–238

A disjunct that entails another within E leaves no set within E that the two super cover satisfying Non-Containment: the logical entailments (98)–(100) with E everything, Figure 1 and (105), the epistemic entailments (102)–(104) with E the speaker's epistemic possibilities under Genuineness, (108), and the modal-internal violations of §6.2 with E the accessible worlds.

theorem not_nonContainment_of_inter_subsetL254–261
{W : Type u_1} {S E A B : Set W} (hAB : A ∩ E ⊆ B) (hSE : S ⊆ E) (h : MinimalCovering.IsSuperCover {A, B} S) :
¬NonContainment {A, B} S

Built from

A disjunct that entails another within E has no world of a set within E to itself, so no such set satisfies Alternativeness: the epistemic entailment with a third disjunct, (103), which meets the other constraints.

theorem not_alternativeness_of_inter_subsetL263–269
{W : Type u_1} {C : Set (Set W)} {S E A B : Set W} (hA : A ∈ C) (hB : B ∈ C) (hAB : A ≠ B) (hE : A ∩ E ⊆ B) (hSE : S ⊆ E) :

Built from

L272–273

Henry (103)

Henry may be a graduate student, chronically stressed, or upset that the Steelers lost, and the speaker believes all graduate students are chronically stressed. The worlds number the combinations the speaker leaves open.