Docs / Studies / Studies.Selkirk1996

The Prosodic Structure of Function Words

Selkirk, E. O. (1996). In Signal to Syntax: Bootstrapping from Speech to Grammar in Early Acquisition (pp. 187–214). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates

Selkirk 1996 gives a function word before a lexical word four possible prosodic structures: a prosodic word of its own, or a clitic that is a daughter of the phonological phrase (free), of the lexical word's prosodic word (internal), or of a prosodic word over that one (affixal). Which is realized follows from the ranking of two constraints on prosodic domination, Exhaustivity at the phrase and Nonrecursivity at the word, with the constraints aligning the edges of lexical words and prosodic words. A stressless function word cannot be a prosodic word, since Headedness is never violated; the English ranking selects the free clitic, and three rankings select the three clitics of three dialects of Serbo-Croatian.

Implementation notes

Violations are computed from the definitions of the constraints. The outer prosodic word of the affixal clitic begins at the function word, so that structure violates the left-edge alignment of prosodic words with lexical words as well as Nonrecursivity. The hierarchy of Prosody.Level ends at the intonational phrase, so the isolation form is stated without the utterance node.

TODO

The phrase-final function words, whose strong form follows from the alignment of maximal projections with phonological phrases, the object pronouns, and the English and Serbo-Croatian forms themselves are not formalized.

References

The four structures

L62–73

The constraints

L87–92
L94–95
L97–105

The violations of the four structures, (25): the free clitic violates only Exhaustivity at the phrase, the affixal clitic Nonrecursivity at the word and the alignment of the left edge of a prosodic word, the internal clitic the alignment of the left edges both ways, and the function word as a prosodic word Headedness and the alignment of both edges of a prosodic word.

theorem violationsL107–117
(c : Con) :
(marks Parse.free.tree c ≠ 0 ↔ c = Con.exh) ∧ (marks Parse.affixal.tree c ≠ 0 ↔ c = Con.nonRec ∨ c = Con.pwdConL) ∧ (marks Parse.internal.tree c ≠ 0 ↔ c = Con.wdConL ∨ c = Con.pwdConL) ∧ (marks Parse.word.tree c ≠ 0 ↔ c = Con.headedness ∨ c = Con.pwdConL ∨ c = Con.pwdConR)

Built from , ,

Rankings

A stressless function word is not a prosodic word: under every ranking with Headedness undominated, the structure in which the function word is a prosodic word loses to the free clitic.

theorem word_notMem_optimalL135–142

Built from , ,

English nonfinal function words are free clitics: under every ranking with the alignment of lexical words and Nonrecursivity at the word over the alignment of prosodic words and Exhaustivity at the phrase, the free clitic is optimal.

theorem english_freeL144–150

Built from , , ,

Three rankings, three clitics, (47): with Nonrecursivity and Exhaustivity over the alignment constraints the internal clitic is optimal; with Exhaustivity under the others, the free clitic; and with the alignment of lexical words and Exhaustivity over Nonrecursivity and the alignment of prosodic words, the affixal clitic.

theorem serboCroatianL152–165

Built from , , ,

The hierarchies of the paper

The paper states each grammar as strata, leaving the order within a stratum open. Each ranking below lists the strata in order, with Headedness first, and is one of the rankings its theorem quantifies over.