Docs / Studies / Studies.Knick2026

Future shifting with present marking in Khalkha Mongolian

Knick, E. (2026). Semantics of Natural Languages, 1(1), 1–51

Knick argues that Khalkha -nA, described as a non-past, is a present tense. With one conjoined subject's eventuality at the utterance time and the other's after it, a non-past sentence is true and the present is not, and a non-past perfect is true of an event at any time. The bare verb is perfective, and the present perfective holds only where every moment is the run time of an eventuality, as with a state. The future is a silent modal over a silent prospective, an eventuality to come; the modal selects a world and so commutes with negation. Aktionsart thus predicts the readings.

Implementation notes

  • A sentence is the set of worlds in which it holds at the utterance time, an interval. The rule that a simple present sentence hold at every part of the utterance time is built into the present tense. It is idle on a property closed under subintervals, the future structure and the negated present perfective among them; under it the negated future excludes an eventuality that starts within the utterance time, which the future does not include.
  • The non-past quantifies over reference times no part of which precedes the utterance time, those standing to it in IntervalAlgebra.startsNoEarlier, the mirror image of the nonfuture reference times of Matthewson 2006.
  • The perfect is the library's, whose span ends with the reference interval, where the paper's may end before it; over the perfective the two agree (Aspect.mem_perfect_iff_of_isUpperSet).
  • A subject's eventualities are those of its predicate, and a distributive reading of conjoined subjects places an eventuality of each within the reference time.
  • A universal modal over a realistic base commutes with negation only when the base is trivial, which is why the paper's first modal gives way to the selectional one.
  • The modal base at a reference time is a relation between worlds, the base of a world its successors. A circumstantial base is realistic, the relation reflexive, as historical alternatives are (Temporal.TWFrame.alt); selection from it returns the world of evaluation, so the modal is the identity.
  • Negation is interpreted where the paper's structure for the negated future has it, above the modal and the prospective. Beneath the prospective it would negate the perfective at some future time within the salient interval, which the affirmative leaves open.
  • A stative predicate is one with the subinterval property and an eventive predicate one whose events take time; achievements, which are instantaneous, fail the present perfective by not recurring at every moment.

TODO

  • The restriction of the prospective to the perfective is the paper's stipulation; the present-only readings of the perfect and the imperfective are not derived.
  • The morphosyntax of the negator -güi, the diagnostics for the modality of -kh and modal subordination are left in prose.

References

The present and the non-past

L81–84
L86
L88–89
L96–97
L100–102

The present perfective

L152–155

The modal

L204–207

The future

L212–216

Over a realistic base the future holds where an eventuality of the predicate lies within the salient interval after the utterance time (42); the rule (28) is idle on it.

theorem mem_present_future_iffL226–231
{W : Type u_1} {T : Type u_2} {E : Type u_3} [LinearOrder T] [TemporalTrace E T] {P : W → E → Prop} {u g : NonemptyInterval T} {w : W} {s : Conditional.SelectionFunction W} {R : NonemptyInterval T → SetRel W W} [∀ (t : NonemptyInterval T), (R t).IsRefl] :
w ∈ present u (future s R g (Aspect.PRFV P)) ↔ ∃ (e : E), TemporalTrace.τ e ≤ g ∧ u.Precedes (TemporalTrace.τ e) ∧ P w e

Built from ,

L234–242

With one subject's eventualities within the utterance time and the other's after it (26a), the non-past sentence is true, and the sentence is false on the present structure and on the future structure alike.

theorem nonPast_and_not_present_of_splitL250–267
{W : Type u_1} {T : Type u_2} {E : Type u_3} [LinearOrder T] [TemporalTrace E T] {P Q : W → E → Prop} {u g : NonemptyInterval T} {w : W} {s : Conditional.SelectionFunction W} {R : NonemptyInterval T → SetRel W W} [∀ (t : NonemptyInterval T), (R t).IsRefl] (hP : ∃ (e : E), P w e) (hQ : ∃ (e : E), Q w e) (hP' : ∀ (e : E), P w e → TemporalTrace.τ e ≤ u) (hQ' : ∀ (e : E), Q w e → u.Precedes (TemporalTrace.τ e)) :
(w ∈ nonPast u fun (v : W) => Aspect.PRFV P v ∩ Aspect.PRFV Q v) ∧ (w ∉ present u fun (v : W) => Aspect.PRFV P v ∩ Aspect.PRFV Q v) ∧ w ∉ present u (future s R g fun (v : W) => Aspect.PRFV P v ∩ Aspect.PRFV Q v)

Built from , ,

The readings of a bare verb