Docs / Studies / Studies.GinzburgFernandezSchlangen2014

Disfluencies as intra-utterance dialogue moves

Ginzburg, J., Fernández, R. & Schlangen, D. (2014). Semantics and Pragmatics, 7(9), 1–64

This file formalizes the account of disfluencies of Ginzburg et al. 2014, on which a self-correction or a hesitation is a dialogue move made inside an utterance and licensed as a clarification request is: the utterance in progress sits in PENDING, a question about one of its constituents is accommodated as MaxQUD, and what follows must be co-propositional with that question. Backward Looking Appropriateness Repair (48) accommodates what the speaker meant by a constituent u0, with u0 as focus-establishing constituent; the Forward Looking Utterance Rule (65), triggered by an editing phrase such as uh, accommodates what the speaker means to say after u0, with none. Both are clarification rules of the gameboard (Gameboard.clarify) that leave the turn open, so the alteration may come from either participant, and Pending replacement (40) then replaces the utterance in progress.

Co-propositionality (34) is derived rather than stipulated: questions denote partial functions from records to propositions, two questions are co-propositional when some record makes them the same proposition, and a move is co-propositional with a question when the question it contributes to QUD is. Since what the speaker meant by u0 ranges over the type of u0's denotation, quite a bit answers the question what was meant by a little bit and swimming does not (Act.copropositional_mean_iff), and the examples of §§3–5 are licensed exactly when acceptable (rows_licensed). The derivations of (41) and (49) reach the gameboards (43) and (52) (Ex41.dgb2, Ex49.dgb2). A self addressed query such as what's his name? (72a) is not co-propositional with what the speaker means to say next (not_copropositional_named), so under (34) the Forward Looking Utterance Rule does not license it (rows_selfAddressed).

Implementation notes

  • A record is empty or has one field (Option Entity). A polar question is defined on every record, any record being of the empty record type, and a wh-question on the records of its domain. A proposition predicates a body of an entity, so propositions are equal when predicate and argument are, as the examples of (34b) assume.
  • Fragments carry the content short-answer resolution gives them (Boston asserts MeanNextUtt(A, in, Boston)); resolution itself is not modelled.
  • An utterance in progress has no represented content (Act.inProgress), and its constituents list only the sub-utterances the examples repair, which covers the non-constituent reparandum of (63c) too.
  • Grounding (31) asks that the locutionary proposition be true, which is not represented: Move update/Pending downdate (ground) integrates MaxPending unconditionally, and the facts Utterance Interpolation adds about the speech event are left out.
  • SubstInst (40b) holds of any two utterances whose fields have fixed types, so Pending replacement constrains only which utterance is replaced; that the replacement reflects the speaker's intention is its argument.
  • The paper licenses (41) by Parameter identification (36), whose simplified formulation leaves the turn open; with the turn change of Ginzburg 2012 (70), A's own continuation is Backward Looking Appropriateness Repair with the turn kept.

TODO

  • (44) and (53) show QUD empty after an acceptance that MOVES does not record; the derivations here stop at Pending replacement, with QUD as Utterance Interpolation left it.
  • The short answer Boston (67) resolves against an empty FEC, which the fragment rule of Ginzburg 2012, matching the fragment's category against the FEC's, does not allow; the paper does not address this.
  • (57), whose alteration that's red is sentential, needs the inference from answer to Pending replacement the paper mentions, and the embedded correction (62) needs the first place to refer to u1.
  • The universal (14) on negation as an editing phrase, the counts of Table 1, and the type refinement of Pending extension (39b) are not represented.

References

Declarations

L98–116
L118–126
L143–155
L283–290

The examples

L352–356
L390–395
L401–408

Cross-turn self-correction: (41) p. 9:35

The correction answers what A meant by Georges, and its polar question is pushed.

theorem Ex41.dgb2(43)L453–458
:
run [Rule.pendingUpdate u₀ Agent.A Agent.B, Rule.backwardRepair Discourse.Gameboard.Turn.keep georges u₁, Rule.assertQud] initial = some { speaker := Agent.A, addressee := Agent.B, moves := [u₁], pending := [u₀], qud := [{ question := Question.polar { body := Body.mean Agent.A georges, arg := Entity.jacques } }, { question := Question.meant Agent.A georges, focusEstablishing := {georges} }] }

Built from , , , , ,

Mid-utterance self-correction: (49) p. 9:43