Docs / Studies / Studies.CiardelliGroenendijkRoelofsen2009

Attention! ‘Might’ in Inquisitive Semantics

Ciardelli, I., Groenendijk, J. & Roelofsen, F. (2009). In Proceedings of Semantics and Linguistic Theory (SALT) 19 (pp. 91–108)

Ciardelli, Groenendijk and Roelofsen let a sentence express a set of possibilities that may include non-maximal ones, so that besides providing and requesting information it can draw attention to possibilities. Their restricted semantics keeps only the maximal possibilities and their unrestricted semantics keeps them all. The maximal possibilities for a formula are its restricted possibilities and both cover its truth set, so the two semantics agree on inquisitive and informative content. Might φ, the formula ⊤ ∨ φ, is the tautology in the restricted semantics, and in the unrestricted one it is attentive just when φ has a possibility other than the trivial one. The non-informative closure ?φ is attentive just when φ is, so only the closures of non-attentive formulas are questions.

Implementation notes

  • The language is the modal-free fragment of Inquisitive.Formula, the language of inquisitive logic; the modalities receive the trivial proposition, and the theorems about them assume Inquisitive.Formula.IsModalFree.
  • The alternative closure ALT (Definition 2) is the set of maximal elements, and the propositional closure PRO (Definition 13) is Inquisitive.Unrestricted.pro.
  • The two semantics are compared through the proposition of inquisitive logic, Inquisitive.proposition, which the possibilities of either generate.
  • Worlds form a finite type, as the indices over finitely many proposition letters do.

References

Declarations

L59–68

Restricted and unrestricted possibilities (§3.1)

Might (§3.2)

Questions and attentiveness (§3.3)