Docs / Syntax / Person / CaseConstraint

The Person Case Constraint

import Linglib.Syntax.Person.CaseConstraint · namespace PCC

The Person Case Constraint restricts which combinations of indirect and direct object person a clitic cluster can realize, the classic ban of French me lui. A combination is a scenario (Clause.Scenario) of the indirect over the direct object, and a variety of the constraint is a predicate on scenarios. The four varieties of the descriptive literature are PCC.Strong, PCC.Ultrastrong, PCC.Weak and PCC.MeFirst. Each is upward closed in the scenario order over the person lattice, which raises the indirect object and lowers the direct object, and Strong entails Ultrastrong, which entails Weak and Me-first.

Implementation notes

Which mechanism enforces the constraint is left open: a morphological filter, φ-Agree and perspectival semantics have all been proposed, and each account is formalized in its study and compared there with these varieties. The literature states the varieties over combinations of distinct persons; on a reflexive combination Ultrastrong is stated here as Strong and Me-first as licit.

References

The varieties

L66

Upward closure

L79
L81–85

Entailments among the varieties

The combinations of the standard tripartition