Docs / Semantics / Attitudes / NegRaising

Neg-raising predicates

import Linglib.Semantics.Attitudes.NegRaising · namespace NegRaising

A neg-raising predicate such as think or want quantifies universally over a modal base, and its negation is understood as the predicate applied to the negated complement. The accounts of this share one proposition, the excluded middle: the modal base settles the complement (NegRaising.excludedMiddle). Together with the negated universal it yields the lowered reading (NegRaising.compl_core_inter_excludedMiddle). The accounts differ on its status. On the presuppositional account the predicate presupposes it (NegRaising.box), so the negation is true exactly where the modal base is nonempty and lies outside the complement (NegRaising.posExt_negation) and is anti-additive in the complement (NegRaising.isAntiAdditive_posExt_negation). On the scalar account the predicate is the plain universal SetRel.core and the excluded middle is its alternative.

Implementation notes

  • NegRaising.box takes a second relation besides the modal base, giving the worlds at which the complement's own presupposition must hold. For think and for want these are the subject's belief worlds: the complement's presupposition is inherited as a belief of the subject.
  • The excluded middle of NegRaising.box is taken about the truth set of the complement, so a complement's own presupposition is cancelled inside it and projects only through the second relation.

References

The excluded middle

L57–58
L60–62

The presuppositional account

The presuppositional neg-raising predicate over the modal base R, as an operator on a complement (Gajewski 2007). It presupposes the excluded middle of R about the complement's truth set and that the complement's presupposition holds throughout H, and it asserts the complement throughout R.

boxL76–83
noncomputable def NegRaising.box {W : Type u_1} (R H : SetRel W W) (φ : W → Trivalent) :
W → Trivalent

The definition is too large to print here; read it in the source.

Used by box_ne_undefined_iff, box_eq_false_iff, box_self_eq_false_iff, negation

Used in Gajewski2007, Romoli2013b

L103–112
L126–130