Docs / Semantics / ArgumentStructure / EntailmentProfile / ArgumentSelection

Argument selection

import Linglib.Semantics.ArgumentStructure.EntailmentProfile.ArgumentSelection · namespace ArgumentStructure.EntailmentProfile

Dowty's argument selection principle compares two arguments of a predicate by counting. The one with more Proto-Agent entailments is lexicalized as subject, and on a tie the one with fewer Proto-Patient entailments; arguments with equal counts may be lexicalized either way. The principle is thus the lexicographic order on a pair of counts, EntailmentProfile.selectionRank, and EntailmentProfile.Outranks inherits what that order has: it is a strict weak order, so role hierarchies are chains, and two arguments alternate when neither outranks the other. Of two nonsubject arguments, the one with more Proto-Patient entailments is lexicalized as direct object and the other as oblique, again a strict weak order. The principle counts entailments, so a profile whose entailments of a cluster strictly include another's is selected over it, though a profile may be selected over another without including its entailments.

Implementation notes

selectionRank reads the Proto-Agent clause of the principle first and lets the Proto-Patient clause decide ties, and "approximately equal" in the corollaries is read as equal.

References

Subject selection

By the selection principle (Dowty 1991 (31)), p is lexicalized as subject over q when it has strictly more Proto-Agent entailments, or as many and strictly fewer Proto-Patient entailments.

def OutranksL47–50

Built from

Used by outranks_iff, instDecidableOutranks, isStrictWeakOrder_outranks, Outranks.trans, Outranks.asymm, alternates_iff, outranks_or_alternates_or_outranks, Outranks.of_alternates_left, Outranks.of_alternates_right, outranks_of_protoAgent_ssubset, outranks_of_protoAgent_nonempty

Used in Semantics/ArgumentStructure/AgentivityLattice/OfEntailmentProfile, Dowty1991, Grimm2011

L86

Object selection