Yukatek Maya Roots as B&K-G Entailment Sets #
A representative cross-section of Yukatek roots, drawn from the lists in [Luc94] ex. (1), (2), (4), and (7), and encoded as [BKG20]-style entailment sets.
The selection covers all four salience profiles that [Luc94]
identifies in Yukatek (agent-salient, agent-patient salient,
patient-salient, positional). The roots feed into the operator
inventory in Operators.lean and the orbit-derivation in
Studies/Lucy1994.lean.
| Source | Root | gloss | profile | Lucy class |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ex. (1a) | siit' | "jump" | manner | agent-salient |
| (text p. 628) | tziib | "write" | manner | agent-salient |
| ex. (1b) | kuc | "carry" | manner, root transitive | agent-patient salient |
| (text p. 629) | pis | "measure" | manner, root transitive | agent-patient salient |
| (text p. 629) | los | "punch" | manner, root transitive | agent-patient salient |
| ex. (1c) / (2) | kiim | "die" | result | patient-salient |
| ex. (2) | haanCease | "stop, cease, heal" | result | patient-salient |
| ex. (4) | luub | "fall" | result | patient-salient |
| ex. (4) | ok | "enter, intrude" | result | patient-salient |
| ex. (7) | cin | "bend" | state | positional |
| (Yukatek lex.) | kul | "sit" | state | positional |
The patient-salient list also includes 'ah "wake", wen "sleep",
siih "be born", tú'ub' "be forgotten", k'a'ah "remember",
čú'un "begin", č'en "stop, cease", hó'op' "begin", hé'el "rest",
p'át "remain"; the agent-salient list includes mìis "sweep",
ć'eh "shout", paak "weed". For the motion-roots non-class
argument we add a small representative subset: máan "pass", tàal
"come", b'in "go", nàak "ascend", lìik' "rise". These are all
encoded with becomesState atoms (no .motion atom; see
motion_roots_not_separate_class for why "motion" is not a B&K-G
feature in Lucy's analysis).
Important orthographic note. Yukatek háan "stop/cease/heal" and
hàan "eat" differ in vowel tone (high vs. low). They are distinct
roots with distinct lexical content. We disambiguate by suffixing the
gloss: haanCease here is the patient-salient cessation root;
Yukatek.haanEat (in VerbClasses.lean) is the
inactive-class but internally-caused "eat" verb that
[Boh04] ex. (9) takes as the key applicative exception.
The transcription uses ASCII glosses (no IPA diacritics) for ease of identifier use; original orthography is preserved in docstrings.
síit' "jump" — manner-of-action activity ([Luc94] ex. 1a).
Underived intransitive; takes affective =t to transitivise.
No .motion atom: per [Luc94], motion is not a B&K-G
feature in Yukatek (cf. motion_roots_not_separate_class); jumping
qualifies as a manner-of-action irrespective of whether it
incidentally involves displacement.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.siit = { name := "siit'", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasManner "jumping"} }
Instances For
¢'iib "write" — manner-of-action activity ([Luc94] p. 628).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.tziib = { name := "tziib", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasManner "writing"} }
Instances For
mìis "sweep" — manner-of-action activity ([Luc94] agent-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.miis = { name := "mìis", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasManner "sweeping"} }
Instances For
ć'eh "shout" — manner-of-action activity ([Luc94] agent-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.cheh = { name := "ć'eh", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasManner "shouting"} }
Instances For
paak "weed" — manner-of-action activity ([Luc94] agent-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.paak = { name := "paak", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasManner "weeding"} }
Instances For
Agent-patient salient roots (root transitives, take =∅) #
These roots "require two arguments and refer to events involving the
action of one entity on another" ([Luc94]) — their distinguishing
property is root transitivity (Root.Arity.selectsTheme, recorded
in arity below), not any B&K-G feature configuration. They carry no
becomesState atom: 'measure' and 'punch' entail no change of state
(B&K-G class hit-type surface-contact verbs as manner-only), so
classing them by manner + result would wrongly make every Yukatek
root transitive a Manner/Result-Complementarity violator.
kuč "carry" — manner-of-action, lexically transitive ([Luc94] ex. 1b). Underived transitive; no derivation needed.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.kuc = { name := "kuc", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasManner "carrying"} }
Instances For
p'is "measure" — manner-of-action, lexically transitive ([Luc94] p. 629). No entailed change of state.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.pis = { name := "pis", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasManner "measuring"} }
Instances For
lo'š "punch" — manner-of-action, lexically transitive
([Luc94] p. 629). Surface-contact manner without entailed
result, like B&K-G's hit-type. No .contact atom: contact is
implicit in the manner of striking rather than a B&K-G feature in
Lucy's typology.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.los = { name := "los", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasManner "striking"} }
Instances For
kíim "die" — spontaneous state change ([Luc94] ex. 1c, 2).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.kiim = { name := "kiim", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "dead"} }
Instances For
háan "stop, cease, heal" ([Luc94] patient-salient list,
p. 630, ex. 2). High-tone vowel: distinct from Yukatek.haanEat
"eat" (low-tone hàan), which is inactive-class but
internally caused — see Fragments/Mayan/Yukatek/VerbClasses.lean
and [Boh04] ex. (9).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.haanCease = { name := "háan", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "stopped"} }
Instances For
lúub' "fall" ([Luc94] ex. 4, Table 4). A "motion verb" by
any reasonable cross-linguistic notional taxonomy, but patterns
morphologically with other patient-salient change-of-state roots
in Yukatek. No .motion atom: motion is the issue, not a
feature — see motion_roots_not_separate_class.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.luub = { name := "luub'", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "fallen"} }
Instances For
'ok "enter, intrude" ([Luc94] ex. 4, Table 4). Another
notional motion root that takes =s like patient-salient state
changes.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.ok = { name := "'ok", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "inside"} }
Instances For
Additional patient-salient roots from the page-630 list.
'ah "wake" ([Luc94] patient-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.ah = { name := "'ah", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "awake"} }
Instances For
wen "sleep" ([Luc94] patient-salient list). State change into sleep, not the activity of sleeping.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.wen = { name := "wen", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "asleep"} }
Instances For
siih "be born" ([Luc94] patient-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.siih = { name := "siih", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "born"} }
Instances For
tú'ub' "be forgotten" ([Luc94] patient-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.tuub = { name := "tú'ub'", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "forgotten"} }
Instances For
k'a'ah "remember" ([Luc94] patient-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.kaah = { name := "k'a'ah", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "remembered"} }
Instances For
čú'un "begin" ([Luc94] patient-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.chuun = { name := "čú'un", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "begun"} }
Instances For
č'en "stop, cease" ([Luc94] patient-salient list).
Distinct from haanCease (Lucy lists them as separate entries).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.chenCease = { name := "č'en", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "ceased"} }
Instances For
hó'op' "begin" ([Luc94] patient-salient list). Doublet of
chuun; both gloss as "begin" in the patient-salient list.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.hoop = { name := "hó'op'", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "started"} }
Instances For
hé'el "rest" ([Luc94] patient-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.heel = { name := "hé'el", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "rested"} }
Instances For
p'át "remain" ([Luc94] patient-salient list).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.paat = { name := "p'át", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "remaining"} }
Instances For
Motion roots from [Luc94] Table 4. These pattern as
patient-salient (becomesState only) — the central typological
point. See motion_roots_not_separate_class and
motion_roots_predicted_patient.
máan "pass" ([Luc94] Table 4).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.maan = { name := "máan", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "passed"} }
Instances For
tàal "come" ([Luc94] Table 4).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.taal = { name := "tàal", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "arrived"} }
Instances For
b'in "go" ([Luc94] Table 4).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.bin = { name := "b'in", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "departed"} }
Instances For
nàak "ascend" ([Luc94] Table 4). Distinct from
Yukatek.naak "ascend" in VerbClasses.lean, which encodes
Bohnemeyer's stem-class data; both refer to the same Yukatek root.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.naak = { name := "nàak", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "ascended"} }
Instances For
lìik' "rise" ([Luc94] Table 4).
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.liik = { name := "lìik'", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.becomesState "risen"} }
Instances For
čin "bow, bend down, bend over" ([Luc94] ex. 5, 7).
Positional root; takes -tal (or -lah) for the inchoative stem.
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.cin = { name := "cin", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasState "bent"} }
Instances For
kul "sit" — positional root (cf. [Luc94] ex. 8c on relational positional semantics: "x is-seated [on y]").
Equations
- Yukatek.Roots.kul = { name := "kul", entailments := {Verb.LexEntailment.hasState "seated"} }
Instances For
Root arity #
The root transitives of this sample — [Luc94]'s =∅ class
("some 500 roots form a transitive in this way"; here the three
sampled members).
Instances For
Coon arity for the sampled roots: the =∅ class selects a theme
([Coo19]'s √TV); every other sampled root is intransitive.
Equations
Instances For
Per-root kind signatures #
Agent-salient roots → {.manner}.
Agent-patient salient (root-transitive) roots → {.manner}.
Patient-salient roots → {.result}.
Motion roots (also patient-salient) → {.result}.
Positional roots → {.state}.
Per-root closed kind signatures #
The collocational closure (Root.Kinds.close) adds .state
to any signature containing .result, and .result + .state to
any containing .cause. No Yukatek root here carries a .cause
atom, so only the result→state edge fires. Closure does not
change the Lucy 1994 salience class predicted by classOf for
these roots: arity is closure-invariant, the agent / patient arms
ignore .state membership, and the positional arm (signature
exactly {.state}) is never produced by closure from a
non-positional base without .cause
(cf. Lucy1994.predictedClass_closure_invariant).
The agent-salient roots in this fragment: roots with manner only,
expected to take affective =t.
Equations
Instances For
The agent-patient salient roots: roots with manner and result,
expected to take zero derivation =∅.
Equations
Instances For
The patient-salient roots (excluding the motion subset): roots with
result only, expected to take causative =s.
Equations
- One or more equations did not get rendered due to their size.
Instances For
The notional motion roots: cross-linguistically "motion" verbs that [Luc94] shows pattern as patient-salient (not as a separate class) in Yukatek.
Equations
Instances For
The positional roots: pure stative roots, expected to take -tal.