Extraction Morphology ↔ Accessibility Hierarchy Bridge #
@cite{keenan-comrie-1977}
Maps between Typology.ExtractionTarget (5 structural positions from
extraction morphology, defined in Typology/Extraction.lean) and
Core.AHPosition (6 positions on the @cite{keenan-comrie-1977}
Accessibility Hierarchy).
Both type systems encode overlapping Ā-movement phenomena: extraction
focuses on where extraction occurs (used by Mayan, Austronesian,
Celtic Fragments); the AH focuses on what can be relativized (used
by relativization Fragments and the Keenan-Comrie hierarchy
constraints). The bridge is partial: AHPosition.objComparison (object
of comparison, specific to the relativization literature) has no
standard ExtractionTarget equivalent. In the other direction,
ExtractionTarget.possessor maps to AHPosition.genitive.
Map an extraction target to its AH position. Possessor extraction corresponds to the genitive position on the AH.
Equations
- Typology.Relativization.extractionTargetToAH Typology.ExtractionTarget.subject = Core.AHPosition.subject
- Typology.Relativization.extractionTargetToAH Typology.ExtractionTarget.directObject = Core.AHPosition.directObject
- Typology.Relativization.extractionTargetToAH Typology.ExtractionTarget.indirectObject = Core.AHPosition.indirectObject
- Typology.Relativization.extractionTargetToAH Typology.ExtractionTarget.oblique = Core.AHPosition.oblique
- Typology.Relativization.extractionTargetToAH Typology.ExtractionTarget.possessor = Core.AHPosition.genitive
Instances For
Map an AH position to an extraction target (partial:
objComparison has no standard ExtractionTarget equivalent).
Equations
- Typology.Relativization.ahToExtractionTarget Core.AHPosition.subject = some Typology.ExtractionTarget.subject
- Typology.Relativization.ahToExtractionTarget Core.AHPosition.directObject = some Typology.ExtractionTarget.directObject
- Typology.Relativization.ahToExtractionTarget Core.AHPosition.indirectObject = some Typology.ExtractionTarget.indirectObject
- Typology.Relativization.ahToExtractionTarget Core.AHPosition.oblique = some Typology.ExtractionTarget.oblique
- Typology.Relativization.ahToExtractionTarget Core.AHPosition.genitive = some Typology.ExtractionTarget.possessor
- Typology.Relativization.ahToExtractionTarget Core.AHPosition.objComparison = none
Instances For
ExtractionTarget → AH → ExtractionTarget is the identity.
AH → ExtractionTarget → AH is the identity for every position
except objComparison (which has no ExtractionTarget).
objComparison is the only AH position without an ExtractionTarget.
Every non-objComparison AH position has an ExtractionTarget equivalent.