Docs / Semantics / Plurality / Reciprocal / Scope

Reciprocal scope: anaphoric relations, locus, and readings

import Linglib.Semantics.Plurality.Reciprocal.Scope · namespace Reciprocal

On the relational analysis of reciprocals (Sternefeld, Beck, Dotlačil, Haug and Dalrymple) each other is a pronoun bearing an anaphoric relation to its antecedent; on the quantificational analysis (Heim, Lasnik and May) it contains a distributive quantifier. The narrow/wide scope ambiguity of a reciprocal in a complement clause is then, relationally, the ambiguity Williams found in any plural anaphor between group identity with the matrix subject (the we-reading) and binding by it (the I-reading).

The relations are conditions on plural information states in Semantics/Dynamic/PPCDRT.lean. This file holds their labels and the two-parameter classification of readings of Haug and Dalrymple §3.3: the locus of the reciprocal, high or low, crossed with the antecedent relation. Three of the four cells are attested; a bound local antecedent denotes an individual and so does not make available the plurality a low reciprocal needs.

Main definitions

References

Declarations

The three anaphoric relations Dalrymple and Haug label their arrows with (the arrow is Higginbotham's, the binding/group-identity ambiguity Williams's): properties of a resolution rather than of the pronoun, since the same they can be bound or group-identical.

inductive AnaphoricRelationL49–60
  • binding : AnaphoricRelation

    The pronoun is a bound variable of its antecedent and denotes an individual.

  • groupIdentity : AnaphoricRelation

    The pronoun denotes the same plurality as its antecedent.

  • reciprocity : AnaphoricRelation

    The same plurality across situations and distinct individuals in each.

Derives DecidableEq, Repr.

Used by ScopeReading

L77–78

The scope readings of a reciprocal in a complement clause.

inductive ScopeL80–86
  • narrow : Scope

    The we-reading: "Tracy and Chris each thought 'We saw each other'".

  • wide : Scope

    The I-reading: "Tracy thought 'I saw Chris' and Chris thought 'I saw Tracy'".

Derives DecidableEq, Repr, Fintype.

Used by Scope.reading

Used in DalrympleHaug2024