Docs / Semantics / Degree / Marginality / Basic

Marginal and large differences

import Linglib.Semantics.Degree.Marginality.Basic

Dinis and Jacinto's ML theory orders degrees by smaller than together with a relation of being marginally smaller, and a degree is largely smaller than another when it is smaller but not marginally so. A MarginalScale is a linear order with such a relation obeying the five axioms of their 2026 paper, which simplify the original theory of 2025. Largely smaller than is a strict weak order whose incomparability is at most marginal difference, so the degrees fall into blocks, the degrees that Cresswell builds from the comparison largely smaller than, and taking a degree to its block is monotone.

References

Declarations

A marginal scale is a linear order with a relation of being marginally smaller, subject to the five axioms of ML theory. A degree is largely smaller than another when it is smaller but not marginally smaller.

structure MarginalScaleL35–61
(α : Type u_1) [LinearOrder α] :
Type u_1
  • MarginallyLT : α → α → Prop

    x is marginally smaller than y.

  • exists_large : ∃ (x : α) (y : α), x < y ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT x y

    Axiom 1 says that some element is largely smaller than another.

  • lt_of_marginallyLT ⦃x y : α⦄ : self.MarginallyLT x y → x < y

    Axiom 2 says that marginally smaller than implies smaller than.

  • irrelevance ⦃x y : α⦄ (z : α) : self.MarginallyLT x y → (z < y ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT z y → z < x ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT z x) ∧ (x < z ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT x z → y < z ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT y z)

    Axiom 3, M-irrelevance, says that when x is marginally smaller than y, whatever is largely smaller than y is largely smaller than x, and y is largely smaller than whatever x is largely smaller than.

  • extends_lt ⦃x y : α⦄ (z : α) : x < y → (y < z ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT y z → x < z ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT x z) ∧ (z < x ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT z x → z < y ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT z y)

    Axiom 4 says that whatever is smaller than something largely smaller than z is largely smaller than z, and whatever is largely smaller than something smaller than z is largely smaller than z.

  • decomposition ⦃x y : α⦄ : x < y ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT x y → (∃ (z : α), self.MarginallyLT x z ∧ z < y ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT z y) ∧ ∃ (w : α), self.MarginallyLT w y ∧ x < w ∧ ¬self.MarginallyLT x w

    Axiom 5, Decomposition, says that a large difference is a marginal step followed by a large one, and a large one followed by a marginal step.

Instances DinisJacinto2025.instIsEmptyMarginalScale

Used by MarginalScale.ext_iff, MarginalScale.ext, MarginalScale.LargelyLT, MarginalScale.AtMostMarginal, MarginalScale.atMostMarginal_iff, MarginalScale.exists_largelyLT, MarginalScale.MarginallyLT.lt, MarginalScale.LargelyLT.lt, MarginalScale.MarginallyLT.not_largelyLT, MarginalScale.MarginallyLT.atMostMarginal, MarginalScale.LargelyLT.exists_marginallyLT_largelyLT, MarginalScale.LargelyLT.exists_largelyLT_marginallyLT, MarginalScale.marginallyLT_or_largelyLT_of_lt, MarginalScale.LargelyLT.of_lt_of_largelyLT, MarginalScale.LargelyLT.trans_lt, MarginalScale.LargelyLT.trans, MarginalScale.MarginallyLT.trans, MarginalScale.MarginallyLT.bounded, MarginalScale.instIsStrictOrderMarginallyLT, MarginalScale.instAsymmLargelyLT, MarginalScale.instIsOrderConnectedLargelyLT, MarginalScale.instIsStrictWeakOrderLargelyLT, MarginalScale.atMostMarginal_iff_incompRel, MarginalScale.AtMostMarginal.refl, MarginalScale.AtMostMarginal.symm, MarginalScale.AtMostMarginal.trans, MarginalScale.atMostMarginalSetoid, MarginalScale.AtMostMarginal.largelyLT_congr_left, MarginalScale.AtMostMarginal.largelyLT_congr_right, MarginalScale.marginallyLT_iff_lt_and_atMostMarginal, MarginalScale.LargelyLT.not_atMostMarginal, MarginalScale.Block, MarginalScale.toBlock, MarginalScale.instLinearOrderBlock, MarginalScale.Block.ind, MarginalScale.toBlock_surjective, MarginalScale.toBlock_lt_toBlock, MarginalScale.toBlock_eq_toBlock, MarginalScale.toBlock_le_toBlock, MarginalScale.toBlock_mono, MarginalScale.toBlockHom, MarginalScale.toBlockHom_coe, MarginalScale.instNontrivialBlock, MarginalScale.instCountableBlock, MarginalScale.largelyLT_or_atMostMarginal_or_largelyLT, MarginalScale.ordConnected_setOf_atMostMarginal, MarginalScale.LargelyLT.infinite_setOf, MarginalScale.LargelyLT.infinite_Ioo, MarginalScale.isUpperSet_setOf_largelyLT

Used in Semantics/Degree/Marginality/Constructions, Semantics/Degree/Marginality/Hom, Semantics/Degree/Marginality/Hyperreal, DinisJacinto2025, DinisJacinto2026

L74–75
L77–79
L89
L94–95
L97
L114–115
L117–118
L136
L138–149
L151–152
L159
L190–191

Blocks

The blocks of a marginal scale are its classes of at most marginally different degrees, ordered by largely smaller than. They are the degrees that Cresswell 1976 builds from the comparison largely smaller than.

def MarginalScale.BlockL196–199
{α : Type u_1} [LinearOrder α] (ml : MarginalScale α) :
Type u_1

Built from ,

Used by MarginalScale.toBlock, MarginalScale.instLinearOrderBlock, MarginalScale.Block.ind, MarginalScale.toBlockHom, MarginalScale.instNontrivialBlock, MarginalScale.instCountableBlock

Used in Semantics/Degree/Marginality/Constructions, Semantics/Degree/Marginality/Hom, DinisJacinto2025

L202–203
L208–211
L214
L229–230
L234
L237–239
L241
L243–246
L248–252
L261–263
L265–266